Homer is the hospital and he receives some bad news, he is sterile. At the same time, Marge is out snuggling with Moe at the Sleep Eazy Motel. A few weeks later, she has some morning sickness and after a visit to the hospital, her fears are realized, she is pregnant. She surprises Homer with the pregnancy, but Homer put two and two together and realizes that Marge had cheated on him. He keeps it a secret though, and handles it through drinking. A few months pass and Maggie is brought into the world. Homer nervously says hello to "his" daughter. One night, he reaches his breaking point. He cannot raise another man's daughter, the pressure breaks him. That night he sneaks into Maggie's bedroom and ends it all with a hammer. He buries her body in the back yard. When morning come, Marge goes to feed Maggie and finds that she is missing.